Chef Sarah Grueneberg Built Monteverde into a Chicago Italian Icon. Trattoria Lo So Comes Next.
Episode Details

Sarah Grueneberg grew up between two worlds: the suburbs of Houston, where her mom worked long hours and baked potatoes were dinner on the go, and her grandparents' cattle farm in Victoria, Texas, where the freezer was full of mystery cuts wrapped in white paper and cinnamon rolls cooled on the counter every summer. She was a rebellious teenager who got her GED at 17, enrolled in culinary school, and found, for the first time, a place where the chaos of a kitchen made complete sense.


Her mentor was Chris Shepherd, who hired her at Brennan's Houston because she showed up unannounced after he ghosted her and refused to leave. She became one of the youngest sous chefs in Brennan's history at 22. A sommelier at the restaurant, originally from Chicago, handed her a list of restaurants worth visiting, and that piece of paper eventually changed everything. Missy Robbins called her in for a stage at Spiaggia. Tony Mantuano offered her the job. She called her mom. A month and a half later, she was moving north.


Her first day at Spiaggia was September 1, 2005, the morning Hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf Coast. She met her business partners Meg Sahs and Rob Mosher that week. She met her husband Jamie not long after. And in 2008, she was the chef de cuisine when the Obamas came in to celebrate their first election win, with one of her dishes on the menu.


Top Chef Season 9 came next. She describes it as becoming warrior chef, a different version of herself who had to find a competitive edge to survive. She made it to the finale. On that menu, in the notes to herself, she had already written the name of the restaurant she was going to open: Monteverde. Her last name, Grueneberg, is green mountain in German. In Italy they had called her Sarah Monteverde. It was always the same word.

She and her partners opened Monteverde in 2015 with two things at its center: a pastificio where pasta is made to order at a wooden table under a mirror, so guests can watch, and seven balsamic barrels from Reggio Emilia that crown the room, the result of a trip to Italy at 26 when Andrea Bazzucchi showed her how balsamic is made and she realized it was one of the most misunderstood ingredients in the world.


Eleven-plus years later, Monteverde has 105 employees, closes on Sundays and Mondays to give the team a real break, and is still home to some of the most iconic dishes in Chicago. The tigelle, little bread cakes from Reggio Emilia, split open and filled with burrata and seasonal mostarda and prosciutto butter she invented so she would not waste the ends of a prosciutto when money was tight. Oma's Green Mountain Salad, an homage to her grandmother and the women who made great salads in wooden bowls. The shrimp scampi with blue prawns cooked in the shell on the plancha and finished in brown butter with Calabrian chilies, a dish no one is allowed to take off the menu.


Her cookbook, Listen to Your Vegetables, turns the vegetable into the muse and the pasta into one chapter among sixteen. She wanted to write a pasta book. Her agent said no. She wrote a vegetable book instead, and found a way to make it a sneaky pasta book anyway.


Now she is getting ready to open Trattoria Lo So in Bucktown with her executive chef Bailey, whose wings she has been helping to build for years. Lo So means "I know" in Italian. The concept is humble, neighborhood, wood-burning oven, bronze die pasta, baked pastas, charcoal grill.


What we cover:

  • Growing up between Houston and her grandparents' cattle farm in Victoria, Texas, and how summers in the country turned her into an adventurous eater who understood where food comes from
  • Getting her GED at 17, enrolling in culinary school, and finding the belonging and belonging she could never quite locate in a traditional classroom
  • Meeting Chris Shepherd at Brennan's Houston, the two-day ghosting, the unannounced return, and the moment in the walk-in when he said: Let's see what talks to you
  • Becoming one of Brennan's youngest sous chefs at 22, and what it meant to work in a kitchen with a table inside where cooks were expected to create and present their own dishes every night
  • Moving to Chicago for Spiaggia at 25, arriving the morning Hurricane Katrina hit, and why the timing still feels significant
  • Meeting Jamie, Meg, and Rob on day one at Spiaggia, and the 21-year love affair with the city that followed
  • Cooking for the Obamas the night they won the 2008 election, with one of her own dishes on the menu
  • What is getting lost in professional kitchens today: French sauce work, terrines, pâtés, and the technique behind the simplest things
  • Top Chef Season 9, six Chicagoans on one season, finding her competitive edge, and naming her future restaurant on the finale menu
  • The two aha moments in Italy at 26 that built Monteverde: Andrea Bazzucchi and the balsamic barrels, and watching a chef finish spaghetti in the sauce instead of the water
  • The pasta TV, the pastificio, and what it means to celebrate the craft of pasta making in the dining room
  • The dishes that do not leave: Tigelle and burrata with seasonal mostarda, prosciutto butter born from necessity and a respect for not wasting anything, Oma's Green Mountain Salad, shrimp scampi with blue prawns
  • How a menu becomes a game board with fewer and fewer open squares the longer you are open and the more dishes become new classics
  • Listen to Your Vegetables: What it means to make the vegetable the muse, the 16-chapter structure, the illustrated vegetables as characters, and how to think about produce the way Italian cooks shop the market
  • What is coming next: The Monteverde online marketplace, Trattoria Lo So in Bucktown with Bailey as executive chef, and the Italy R&D trip
  • Recharging: Yoga for two years, live music (Goose, Sade), and flying to Cleveland for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction
  • What she is most proud of: 105 employees, closing on Sundays and Mondays, and the intentionality that came from slowing down during COVID
  • One piece of advice for anyone starting out on their own: Do not listen to the noise

Find Sarah and Monteverde at monteverdechicago.com and on Instagram at @chefsarahjayne and @monteverdechi. Trattoria Lo So opens in early 2027 in the Bucktown neighborhood of Chicago. Signed copies of Listen to Your Vegetables are available through the restaurant, and the Monteverde online marketplace carries merch, cookbooks, hoodies, T-shirts, and bandanas.


This episode is sponsored by Vermont Nut Free Chocolates. Get 20% off your order through December 31st with code PERFECTBITE at vermontnutfree.com.


This episode is also sponsored by BLiS Gourmet, Michigan's small-batch producer of barrel-aged condiments, sauces, and caviar. Use code BLISPB20 for 20% off your order at blisgourmet.com through Thanksgiving, November 26.


This episode is also sponsored by Takeaways. Indulge your salt tooth with Takeaways' cheesy, protein-packed snack bars. Get 20% off with code PERFECTBITE at eattakeaways.com.


This episode is also sponsored by Hej Hej. Treat yourself to imported Swedish candy mixes and experience the art of fika, the Swedish tradition of slowing down for a sweet treat. Get 10% off your order with code SWEET at chefhejhej.com.


Subscribe to The Perfect Bite podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen! Want to watch the entire episode? Head here to our YouTube!


You can follow us on social media @perfectbitepod and sign up for our newsletter!

Episode cover art for Chef Sarah Grueneberg Built Monteverde into a Chicago Italian Icon. Trattoria Lo So Comes Next.
00:00
30:00